Dear Gene,

It would be wonderful to imagine that those who rated these two "lost" Chan films actually had seen them at some point. However, the reality is probably that they engaged in a little prank. The "other criteria" factor that you mention is another possibility, with that criteria perhaps being the "lost" Chan film scripts that we have available right here.

More than a year ago there was a fairly well-substantiated hint that a copy of "Charlie Chan Carries On" was in ther hands of an individual who was seeking to restore that movie. At about the same time, I and a few others of us had a brush with a person who claimed to have seen a French dubbed copy of "Charlie Chan's Chance" which was also laking about a reel of content. So, in the end, who knows?

Sincerely,
Rush Glick