Return to Website

The Charlie Chan Family Message Board

Welcome to our Message Board. Please feel free to post your thoughts, questions, or information.

The Charlie Chan Family Message Board
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
Was Warner Oland the definitive Dr. Fu Manchu?

I noticed that in addition to playing Charlie Chan he also played Dr. Fu Manchu in "The Mysterious Dr. Fu Manchu" (1929), "The Return Of Dr. Fu Manchu" (1930) and"Daughter Of the Dragon (1931). Are these films still around? Or are they lost? If they still exist what studio owns them? Are they on video? Since most people think Warner Oland is the best Charlie Chan, how is Warner Oland as the evil Dr. Fu Manchu? Who is the best Dr. Fu Manchu? Warner Oland, Boris Karloff, Henry Brandon or Christopher Lee? Just Curious?

Re: Was Warner Oland the definitive Dr. Fu Manchu?

Dear Sam,

As to who was the best Fu Manchu, my guess would be Warner Oland, as he was very much associated with that role when he was chosen to portray Charlie Chan. In fact, there is even an "in-joke" reference to Fu Manchu in the words of a song that Charlie Chan sings to a group of children in "Charlie Chan in Shanghai."

I believe that the films you mention are available for viewing. Admittedly, I have never seen them, though!

Sincerely,
Rush

Re: Re: Was Warner Oland the definitive Dr. Fu Manchu?

I would guess Oland was the best Fu Manchu. He is only One of Two actors to play him more than once(The other actor is Christopher Lee), however Boris Karloff is the most famous Fu Manchu. There was a book (I think it was called "Saturday Afternoon At The Bijou"), which had chapters on different movie characters(Like Frankenstein, Tarzan, Sherlock Holmes, Blondie, even Charlie Chan as well as Fu Manchu and there was a picture of Warner Oland as Fu Manchu). Very good book from the 1970's.

Re: Re: Re: Was Warner Oland the definitive Dr. Fu Manchu?

Yes, the 3 Fu films were originally produced by Paramount and now owned by Universal. UCLA has restored them and they look incredible. Sadly, there are rights issues on all three films and they are tied up, thus negating television and video releases.