Good question, and one that would be very interesting to resolve. I would imagine that birth records at that city's government office could give the answer. My guess is that Mr. Toler may have been born on a farm, but that is only a guess. PLease do try to find the answer if you can while there, although you will probably find that the exact location may today be a shopping mall, as much has doubtless changed there during the intervening 130-plus years...
Thanks Rush,
Yes, we will try the city offices and the library there as well to see if they can offer some assistance. Will post if we are successful. Thanks again for suggestion.