Return to Website

The Charlie Chan Family Message Board

Welcome to our Message Board. Please feel free to post your thoughts, questions, or information.

The Charlie Chan Family Message Board
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
A Modern Sherlock Holmes - A Modern Charlie Chan?

The BBC- PBS Mystery is running a contemporary version of Sherlock Holmes. When I read of it a couple of months ago I was instantly suspect of such an idea. Especially since I've not been a fan of the more recent (period) portrayals of Miss Marple. Surprise! I actually found it to be quite good. I prefer a Victorian Holmes, most notably seen with Jeremy Brett as Holmes, but I find they have captured the spirit of Holmes if not the setting. Now if only someone would do this with Chan.... (Though I would prefer 1930s locales)

Re: A Modern Sherlock Holmes - A Modern Charlie Chan?

Dear Russell,

Interesting! However, I would prefer that an "updating" of Charlie Chan would be through the use of a grandson, etc., rather than a "restart" of the character in our era. Minus excessive martial arts, of course!

Sincerely,
Rush