Return to Website

The Charlie Chan Family Message Board

Welcome to our Message Board. Please feel free to post your thoughts, questions, or information.

The Charlie Chan Family Message Board
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
View Entire Thread
Re: Fresh Air on NPR today

You are most welcome, Virginia. We had a "driveway moment", listening to the end of the story when we got home. I knew then, that I would have to find it online and post it for everyone here.

Re: Fresh Air on NPR today

That was most interesting, thank you! I guess I am getting tired of the "Caucasian playing an Asian is unthinkable" mantra. I am sure racism was unfortunately involved in some things, but regarding casting, isn't that why it is called ACTING? Are we going to get so politically correct that someone from Italian descent can only play an Italian in the movies, or an Irishman an Irishman...etc..? If the portrayal is convincing and respectful, I don't see a problem with it...

Re: Fresh Air on NPR today

I just realized . . . they need some fresh air period on this argument.

One of the arguments that I know I had was why just Asian Americans being played by whites?

Sessue Hayakawa was playing the Hispanic role of El Jaguar in the 1917 The Jaguar's Claws.

Should they have used a white actor or is this what we should all be aiming for even now . . . the actor who can do the job or fit the racial role?!

Virginia